Hybrid Feedback — Quick Votes + Discussions

Chapter Outline

Chapter 4: Hybrid Feedback — Quick Votes ✚ Discussions

So far, we’ve built:

  • Quick binary feedback with Airtable (Chapter 2).
  • Discussion threads with Giscus/Disqus (Chapter 3).

Now we’ll combine both into a hybrid feedback system: readers can vote quickly and leave detailed comments — giving you both quantitative and qualitative signals.

4.1 Why Hybrid Matters

  • Votes (Airtable): Capture a quick pulse — was this content helpful?
  • Discussions (Giscus/Disqus): Enable readers to ask questions, suggest improvements, or expand on the topic.
  • Together: You get lightweight validation + deeper engagement.

This mirrors real-world product feedback systems (think: GitHub’s 👍 reactions plus issue comments).

4.2 Airtable ✚ Giscus/Disqus Components

We’ll create:

  1. An AirtableVoteButton for quick yes/no votes.
  2. A GiscusComments or DisqusComments component (from Chapter 3).
  3. A BlogFeedbackSection that combines both.

AirtableVoteButton Component

src/components/AirtableVoteButton.tsx
1import React from 'react';
2

3interface AirtableVoteButtonProps {
4  postSlug: string;
5}
6

7export const AirtableVoteButton: React.FC<AirtableVoteButtonProps> = ({ postSlug }) => {
8  const baseUrl = 'https://airtable.com/shrXXXXXXXX'; // Replace with your Airtable form URL
9  const yesUrl = `${baseUrl}?prefill_Post=${encodeURIComponent(postSlug)}&prefill_Helpful=Yes`;
10  const noUrl = `${baseUrl}?prefill_Post=${encodeURIComponent(postSlug)}&prefill_Helpful=No`;
11

12  return (
13    <div style={{ marginBottom: '1rem' }}>
14      <p>Was this helpful?</p>
15      <a
16        href={yesUrl}
17        target="_blank"
18        rel="noopener noreferrer"
19        style={{ marginRight: '1rem', color: 'green' }}
20      >
21        Yes
22      </a>
23      <a href={noUrl} target="_blank" rel="noopener noreferrer" style={{ color: 'red' }}>
24        No
25      </a>
26    </div>
27  );
28};

BlogFeedbackSection Component (with Giscus)

src/components/BlogFeedbackSection.tsx
1import React from 'react';
2import { AirtableVoteButton } from './AirtableVoteButton';
3import { GiscusComments } from './GiscusComments'; // from Chapter 3
4// Or: import { DisqusComments } from './DisqusComments';
5

6interface BlogFeedbackSectionProps {
7  postSlug: string;
8}
9

10export const BlogFeedbackSection: React.FC<BlogFeedbackSectionProps> = ({ postSlug }) => {
11  return (
12    <section style={{ marginTop: '2rem' }}>
13      <h2>Feedback</h2>
14      <AirtableVoteButton postSlug={postSlug} />
15      <div style={{ marginTop: '2rem' }}>
16        <h3>Join the Discussion</h3>
17        <GiscusComments />
18        {/* Or swap in <DisqusComments /> */}
19      </div>
20    </section>
21  );
22};

Usage in Gatsby Blog Post Template

src/templates/BlogPostTemplate.tsx
1import React from 'react';
2import { BlogFeedbackSection } from '../components/BlogFeedbackSection';
3

4export default function BlogPostTemplate({ children, pageContext }) {
5  const { slug } = pageContext;
6

7  return (
8    <main>
9      <article>{children}</article>
10      <BlogFeedbackSection postSlug={slug} />
11    </main>
12  );
13}
  • pageContext.slug comes from Gatsby’s createPages API.
  • Airtable votes are tagged with the post slug.
  • Giscus/Disqus maps comments to the blog page.

4.3 UX Considerations

  • Placement: Put feedback at the end of posts (after article).
  • Visibility: Keep Airtable votes lightweight, no page reloads.
  • Styling: Style votes as buttons, not links. Consider showing aggregate counts from Airtable (using Airtable API).
  • Choice of system: Use Giscus for dev blogs, Disqus for general audiences.

Later chapters will show how to replace Airtable with your own API and build an analytics dashboard.

4.4 Summary

In this chapter, you:

  • Built an AirtableVoteButton React component.
  • Combined votes + discussions into a BlogFeedbackSection.
  • Embedded it into a Gatsby blog post template.

Now your blog has hybrid feedback: lightweight validation and rich discussions.

4.5 Exercise

  1. Add a BlogFeedbackSection to one of your Gatsby blog posts.
  2. Test the workflow:
    • Submit a Yes/No vote (check Airtable for the record).
    • Leave a comment in Giscus/Disqus.
  3. (Optional) Customize the styles so votes look like modern buttons.

4.6 Next Step

In the next chapter, we’ll go beyond third-party tools and start building our own feedback API with FastAPI (Python) or NestJS (TypeScript) — complete with database schema, REST endpoints, and a simple frontend widget.

Blog
Feedback
Web Dev

Feedback